NYACK, N.Y. — Rockland County’s two acute-care hospitals received contrasting ratings in The Leapfrog Group’s Fall 2026 Hospital Safety Grades, released Wednesday.
Montefiore Nyack Hospital earned an A grade, while Good Samaritan Hospital in Suffern received a C. The biannual report evaluates general hospitals on how effectively they protect patients from preventable harm. Grades range from A to F.
Montefiore Nyack was one of 11 Hudson Valley hospitals to receive the highest mark. Other regional hospitals earning an A included White Plains Hospital, Phelps Hospital in Sleepy Hollow and Putnam Hospital.
Good Samaritan’s C placed it among several Hudson Valley hospitals in the report’s middle tier. Westchester Medical Center in Valhalla, St. Joseph’s Medical Center of Yonkers and Montefiore St. Luke’s Cornwall also received C grades. Montefiore New Rochelle and Montefiore Mount Vernon each received a B.

How the grades are calculated
Leapfrog measures hospital performance across dozens of safety indicators. The categories include hospital-acquired infections, surgical and procedural safety, patient injuries, staffing and medication technology.
The organization combines federal clinical data from the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services and the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention with voluntary data from its annual hospital survey.
Nationwide, Leapfrog assigned A grades to 900 hospitals and B grades to 774 facilities. Another 655 hospitals received a C, while 35 earned a D and three received an F. Connecticut, Utah and New Jersey ranked among the top-performing states.
Montefiore Nyack officials said the grade reflects the hospital’s clinical protocols. The hospital also received Leapfrog’s Full Transparency Badge earlier this year and high-performing designations from U.S. News & World Report for heart failure, kidney failure and pneumonia care.
Criticism and legal challenge
Leapfrog’s methodology has drawn criticism from some hospital administrators and health policy researchers. Smaller and rural hospitals have argued that the formula can favor large urban academic medical centers and penalize facilities that lack certain specialists or technologies.
The organization also faced a legal challenge in Florida over how it scored hospitals that did not complete its voluntary survey. In March 2026, a federal judge in South Florida ruled against Leapfrog in a lawsuit brought by medical centers. Leapfrog is appealing the ruling.
For the Fall 2026 cycle, Leapfrog withheld grades from hospitals that skipped its 2025 or 2026 surveys and listed them as “Grade Not Assigned.”
Health care advocates recommend using safety grades as one factor when evaluating hospitals. Patients can review detailed hospital data through Leapfrog and Medicare’s Care Compare tool and consult their doctors. In an emergency, patients should seek immediate care at the nearest emergency department.
Ten years of experience reporting. From car chases and courtroom verdicts to House fires, Holsford thrives during breaking news and finds it a privilege to help drive the conversation in Rockland County and the Greater New York Area. Born in San Bernardino, Thomas is a New York boy at heart. He received his bachelor’s degree in broadcast journalism, specializing in political science and sociology, from the University of Illinois





